Dietary Carbohydrate restriction as the first approach in diabetes management. Critical review and evidence base, by Richard D Feinman et al.

Another Bookmarking post.

From http://dgeneralist.blogspot.co.uk/2013/11/the-low-carb-high-fat-diet.html

The study in question is Dietary Carbohydrate restriction as the first approach in diabetes management. Critical review and evidence base. Here are my comments on the 12 points.

Point 1 is wrong. For ~85% of people who have T2DM, hyper*emia is the salient feature, where * = glucose, TG's, cholesterol, NEFAs, uric acid etc. For ~85% of people who have T2DM, it's a disease of chronic excess.

Ad lib LCHF diet → ↓ Blood glucose & ↓ fasting TG's, but ↑ PP TG's, ↑ LDL-C, ↑ LDL-P & ↑ NEFAs. See Postprandial lipoprotein clearance in type 2 diabetes: fenofibrate effects.
↑ PP TG's is associated with ↑ RR of CHD.
↑ LDL-P is associated with ↑ RR of CHD.
↑ NEFAs are associated with ↑ RR of Sudden Cardiac Death.

Point 2: So?

Point 3 is wrong. A caloric deficit is essential, to reverse liver & pancreas ectopic fat accumulation. See Reversing type 2 diabetes, the lecture explaining T2D progression, and how to treat it.

Point 4 is misleading. Feinman doesn't distinguish between different types of carbohydrates. Starches, especially resistant starches (e.g. Amylose) are beneficial. See Point 11.

Point 5 is moot. Prof. Roy Taylor found that motivation determines adherence. Prof. Roy Taylor's PSMF was adhered to. See Point 3.

Point 6 is correct. Prof. Roy Taylor's PSMF is ~1g Protein/kg Bodyweight, some ω-6 & ω-3 EFAs & veggies for fibre. See Point 3.

Point 7 is misleading. Siri-Tarino et al gave a null result by including low fat studies, also a dairy fat study which had a RR < 1 for increasing intake. Chowdhury et al gave a null result, as some fats have a RR > 1 for increasing intake and some have a RR < 1 for increasing intake.

Point 8 is irrelevant. ↑ Dietary fat → ↑ 2-4 hour PP TG's. See Point 1.

Point 9 is partly correct. Microvascular, yes. Macrovascular, no. See Point 8.

Point 10 is mostly irrelevant. See Point 8.

Point 11 ignores results obtained with high-starch diets, where the starch contains a high proportion of Amylose. See Walter Kempner, MD – Founder of the Rice Diet and From Table to Able: Combating Disabling Diseases with Food.

Point 12 is misleading. The low-carbohydrate part is fine. It's the high-fat part that can cause problems. See Point 8.

Reversing type 2 diabetes, the lecture explaining T2D progression, and how to treat it.

Julianne Taylor of Paleo & Zone Nutrition posted the following excellent lecture on Facebook:-

Eating Through The Myths: Food, Health and Happiness - Taylor, Prof. R., Berlin, 28-Sep-12

Salient points:

1) It's a chronic calorie excess (of carbohydrates and/or fats) that causes problems.
2) Motivation, motivation, motivation!
3) Both diet and exercise are important. See Move More: Solutions to problems.
4) You can't outrun your fork. See The 5th Myth of Modern Day Dieting: You Can Outrun Your Fork.
5) Underlying Insulin Resistance needs to be addressed. See Insulin Resistance: Solutions to problems.

See also Reversal of type 2 diabetes: normalisation of beta cell function in association with decreased pancreas and liver triacylglycerol, and Pathogenesis of type 2 diabetes: tracing the reverse route from cure to cause.

For more information on Prof. Taylor's work, see Reversing Type 2 Diabetes.